Still using Windows Explorer for file management?
Then let me introduce you to the contenders:
AccelMan v3.5.0 build 3600
XPlorer2 v1.6.5.3
XYPlorer v6.10.0000
Altap Salamander v2.5
AccelMan
———-
AccelMan has the most customizable interface of any application I’ve ever seen. The ‘Managers’ are each dockable and maximizable, allowing for vertical view, horizontal view, tri-view, and just about any other view you can think of. And each manager has its own tab bar, so if you prefer a tabbed interface, go for it. You can customize the toolbars, the colors, and even the context menus (!!!). AccelMan is really a whatever-you-want-it-to-be File Manager. It’s even got its own music player, though I’m not sure why you would want this. One strange (and appreciated) feature is the built-in command line enabled by default. Normally, I’d think that would be tucked away in an option menu since most computer users don’t even know what it is, but it’s right there at the bottom, and in constant use on my computer. AccelMan also has a very intuitive bookmark bar, whereas many other file managers make bookmarking a time-consuming process. AccelMan has a few faults, the main one being that you can’t calculate all folder sizes in the current manager. I guess that’s why there is SpaceMonger. One of my favorite features of AccelMan: Ability to set what the 4th mouse button does. This thing, I love, and it’s almost reason enough to use AccelMan by itself. By default, the 4th button (or back button) on my mouse will go back to the last folder I visited. Using AccelMan, I can set this to go up a directory, instead of back to the last folder I was at. For instance, going from C:\ to E:\Something, hitting the button normally will take me back to C:\. Hitting back in AccelMan can take me to E:\. Note, this feature is optional, and you can actually set the back button to just about anything you want it to do. This feature IS possible to use in other file managers by mapping the 4th mouse button to the backspace key in Logitech MouseWare, but MouseWare is BloatWare, and negatively interferes with my mouse acceleration along with ruining compatability for the extra buttons in various programs (Ventrilo is one that comes to mind).
I was lucky enough to grab this application when it was on GiveAwayOfTheDay.com. Yes, I actually got this amazing application for free (hard to believe they gave it away free, I know).
XPlorer2
———-
XPlorer2 is a great orthodox file manager, possibly the best. With a very clean interface, and a decent set of features, XPlorer2 is very complete file manager. The Lite version has quite a few limitations, but without making the application useless, and it doesn’t go around water-marking all your files
You only get two toolbars in the lite version, but whoever needed more than two? It even lets you remove the donate button. The problem with the toolbar is that there aren’t many buttons to choose from. Only some features can be made into toolbar buttons, and to be specific, all the useless features that already have shortcut key and need not be made into toolbar buttons, can be made into toolbar buttons. The Options menu is very complete, with every option I can think of and would want, lacking only in the fact that it’s not very organized, and to get a full sense of the options, you have to sit down and read 3 pages of menus to find the one you want. One nice feature of XPlorer2 is it’s full set of detail column selections. Any column you want, it has, and then some. One of my favorite features of XPlorer2 is that when you press CTRL + D, XPlorer2 will list for you folder sizes. A very handy feature. Another one of my favorite features is in Tools > Options > Window Tab, under Tree, uncheck ‘Keep synchronized with folder in active view pane’. Personally, I jump in and out of folders a lot, and by the time I’m done the tree menu becomes useless since it has expanded every folder I’ve visited. Disabling the feature in options allowed you to choose when you want to expand a folder, and doesn’t take matters into its own hands. I also keep a button on my Toolbar called ‘Tree sync’, which will expand the tree to the current folder I’m in. The perfect button and the perfect option. One lacking feature in XPlorer2 is that you have to use XP style selection. Other file managers offer a custom file selection so when you miss click once, your selection doesn’t go down the tube. Another missing feature is the lack of a custom shell menu. You have to use the default windows one, except when right clicking a blank area in a pane. This makes the application as slow and clumsy for file operations as Windows File Explorer. Still, being the only decent free file manager out there, XPlorer2 provides a very clean and clear file manager, with things where they should be, and no need for extra customization as everything comes done right.
XYPlorer
———-
XYPlorer is one of my personal favorites, not just because it has a wiki (http://88.191.26.34/XYwiki/index.php), but also because it presents a new kind of interface, venturing out of the old, and into the new (much in the same manner AccelMan does). The only problem with this is that XYPlorer’s best feature is also its worst: There are wonderfully implemented tabs!!!! But you can
Altap Salamander
———-
My first impression of this program was that it looked like it wasn’t what I was looking for in a file manager. But since then, it has grown on me. Going through the configuration menu, I quickly noticed something: This configuration window is the best configuration windows out there. Everything in a neatly ordered expandable treeview, and changing a setting I want would take a matter of seconds in this baby. It also has a great little menu in the config called Change Drive Menu. That menu is possibly my favorite thing in the entire config. Salamander also has a great set of color schemes with it, each effectively implemented. One thing I noticed while using Salamander is that the icons are all effectively backwards. They only color themselves in when you highlight them, and otherwise remain dull and colorless. Why? That’s one feature I could do without. After spending a minute looking for the tree, I realized there is no tree. Hmm? No tree!? Surely this application is missing a few screws. Then I tried navigating a few folders to see how it felt. Not bad! The up arrow .. provides a neat way of going up one level (everyone who has ever used linux/dos will appreciate this) and it also has an intuitive breadcrumb feature, just click which level you want to go to. Selecting files is implemented nicely, exactly the way I’d want it to be. It even has a nice little middle bar, which I do recommend you enable. And the toolbar comes pre-configured with a great selection of buttons. The customization for the toolbar is also great, and I only needed to add one button to my toolbar, the calculate folder sizes button. Initially loading a folder can take a second, but Salamander makes a cache of it after that, and with the cache it browses faster than any of its competitors. Its also very easy to learn the keyboard shorcuts. If you don’t know one, just goto the menu with they button and it will tell you the shortcut. Looking through Slamander, there are only 3 features I miss: The back button on my mouse takes me back, not up a level, the icons are backwards, and the bookmarking is a pain (you’re also limited to 10 bookmarks. Why?!!!). You must do dual panel browsing (no horizonatal or triview, and no tabs) and you can’t use a tree, but other than that the interface is fairly customizable, and works great at the default settings. It has a well-implemented custom drag’n'drop menu (unlike XYPlorer’s buggy one) so it is very fast for drag’n'drop operations (AccelMan is just as fast too), but suffers from the regular right click menu for everything else, making it painfully slow to create an archive of thousands of files in a single directory. Salamander truly has a great feature set, and includes many useful plugins.
Conclusion
———-
Each program has it’s own strengths and weaknesses and I was not able to determine a single winner. Until these managers become perfected, it is my opinion that you will have to make the decision for yourself. I’ve presented you with information on each and with this as your guide you should be able to gut the old Windows Explorer and replace it with a sleek new 3rd party File Manager.



